Vote, or add your own. Post as a guest to stay anonymous.
Look up other companies' values
What we heard: A tester would use Staff to decide which companies to support, and suggested a big company could vet a contractor or agency before hiring. Recommendation: No build now. Note it as a use for company pages once enough companies clear the 3-employee threshold.
Let people flag a missing answer instead of free comments
What we heard: Suggestion: take structured feedback on the question itself ("this missed option E") and summarize it, since "the stats are the gold." Three other testers enjoy commenting. Recommendation: Keep comments. Add a one-word reply for "none of these fit" and report the count with the result.
Show how many people are answering
What we heard: The site feels journalistic but not "credible" yet. A tester asked for counts of people on Staff and respondents per poll. Recommendation: Show respondent counts on each poll once they clear a floor that looks credible. Hold the site-wide total until it is a number worth showing.
Own company listed under "How other companies answered"
What we heard: A poll page showed the tester's own company in the other-companies list. Recommendation: Exclude the viewer's company from that list, or relabel it "How companies answered."
Lead the homepage with today's open poll
What we heard: A first-time visitor assumed the first poll shown was the live one. The page led with yesterday's results and he missed the open-poll box. Recommendation: Make today's open poll the first thing on the page, with its closing time. Put yesterday's result second.
Gender result showed no women
What we heard: During onboarding a tester saw a gender result with no women and wondered who is on Staff. Recommendation: Check whether this is a display bug or a real skew in a small group. If real, do not show a split below a minimum group size.
Let people choose when the poll arrives
What we heard: Noon is the wrong time for some; the prompt gets dismissed. Recommendation: Offer morning, noon or evening by text reply, not an exact time.
Keep personal questions off the front page
What we heard: A cold visitor saw the secret-bank-account question first, found it "intrusive" and unrelated to work, and said she would not sign up. Two other testers liked the after-hours questions. Recommendation: Make the homepage's lead poll a work question. Keep after-hours questions in the feed, where people who already trust Staff find them.
Show people their feedback was heard
What we heard: A tester has given feedback but has no idea where it is in the consideration cycle, or whether it was noted. Recommendation: This board is the fix. Give every post a status and change it when something ships.
Show % on the bar charts
What we heard: Homepage bar graphs do not show percentages, so exact values are a guess. Recommendation: Add % labels to every bar on the homepage and poll pages.
Daily is a lot for some people
What we heard: One tester would not answer every day, especially on busy days. Another quit a daily tracker after five years because it got tedious. Recommendation: Never guilt a skipped day. Add a PAUSE keyword and consider a weekdays-only option.
Match the cartoon to the person's answer
What we heard: Cartoons are on topic but not on answer; a match is a coincidence. One tester tapped the image expecting a link. Recommendation: Start with two cartoon variants on polls with two answers. Hold the rest until the style is settled.
Tell people what the bot can do
What we heard: People forgot the bot's name and that it chats, and would not ask for help unless "help" or "info" was suggested. Occasional nudges are welcome. Off-script replies delight when people find them. Recommendation: End onboarding with one line listing what to text (HELP, a question, a comment). Repeat it about every two weeks.
Give every poll an answer that fits
What we heard: When no option fits, people skip the poll. One tester answered one poll in two weeks for this reason. Scales with a middle help. Recommendation: Add an escape option ("None of these") to multiple-choice polls, and make "does every respondent have a true answer?" a hard check before a poll ships.
Poll page polish: label comments, hide empty sections, add company logos
What we heard: The comment under a poll is unlabeled and reads as a write-in answer. Related and Latest sections show when empty. Company profiles have no logo. Recommendation: Label the comment and add a small anonymous avatar. Hide Related and Latest until they have content. Add logos to company profiles.
Put How it works, FAQ and Join in plain sight
What we heard: How Staff Works and the FAQ are only reachable through the Join now button. One tester asked around before finding the number to text. The page "goes on for a while" without hierarchy. Recommendation: Put How it works, FAQ and About in the top navigation. Make Join a plain call to action with the number visible. Add section headings to the long page.
An unknown number feels like spam
What we heard: One tester renamed the contact "Staff" because an unknown number felt like spam or a money ask. Others would not answer an unsolicited text and would check the website first. Recommendation: Send a contact card during onboarding so the thread is named Staff. Keep invitations pointing to the website, not a cold text.
Make clear which poll each result and cartoon belongs to
What we heard: It is unclear when results and cartoons arrive and which poll they refer to. One tester prefers yesterday's result first, then today's poll. "Tap to load preview" links feel less clickable than results shown in the thread. Recommendation: Fix the daily order: yesterday's result, today's poll, acknowledgment, then cartoon. Restate the question in every result. Send the instant one-line result on vote.
First reply to JOIN is slow and messages arrive out of order
What we heard: About a 1-minute delay on the first reply made a tester wonder "Is it broken?" Another got onboarding messages out of order. Question and result order differs between Android and iPhone. Recommendation: Send an instant one-line acknowledgment to JOIN. Space picture and text messages so they cannot overtake each other, and test on both Android and iPhone.
Cartoons look AI-made
What we heard: "Cute but very AI." AI-image fatigue. One tester suggested commissioning an illustrator for 15 to 20 images to remix. Four other testers like the cartoons and say they make Staff feel real. Recommendation: Ship the approved style, then show it to the three testers who objected before spending on an illustrator.